- Open For Business
- Posts
- Can TCU Derail BYU’s Perfect Start?
Can TCU Derail BYU’s Perfect Start?
And the Senate passes a massive college sports bill
October is here, and that’s when the college football season really gets rolling.
Here’s your Big 12 week five primer!
Are BYU and Texas Tech on Upset Alert?
#10 BYU (3-0, 1-0) at TCU (2-2, 0-1) – 6:00 ESPN
Line: BYU -6.5
#12 Texas Tech (4-0, 1-0) at Colorado (2-2, 0-1) – 6:30 Fox
Line: Tech -12.5
I haven’t been shy about Texas Tech not passing the eye test so far this season. But I’m nowhere near putting the Red Raiders on upset alert at Colorado on Saturday.
Colorado’s defense has been respectable this season, and if Tech QB Will Hammond throws three interceptions in a quarter again, the Buffs may have a chance. I just don’t know how Colorado is going to score.
Tech’s secondary has been vulnerable at times, but Colorado’s offense is a mess right now. Against Power Four opponents this season, the Buffaloes are averaging only 11 points per game. They’re also a wretched 7-for-32 on third and fourth down over the last two games.
There’s also a quarterback controversy now.
Is blue-chip QB Julian Lewis’ confidence shot after being benched for Isaac Wilson at Baylor last week? Wilson probably raises the floor and lowers the ceiling of Colorado’s offense. It sounds like he’s likely to start on Saturday.
Believe it or not, the Red Raiders are only 1-4 all-time in Boulder. This will be Tech’s first trip there in 16 years. The bad news for the Buffaloes is that Kordell Stewart isn’t walking through that door on Saturday.
Things are more interesting in Fort Worth.
It’s a little surprising to see BYU favored by only 6.5 points over TCU. The Horned Frogs are coming off a 21-13 loss at UCF and have stumbled to a 2-2 start.
This looked like a much trickier game for the Cougars before the season started. But it’s still a major opportunity for the Frogs to draw a line in the sand and turn their season around.
If TCU pulls off the upset, it will likely be because its run defense shuts down Cougars RB LJ Martin and the BYU rushing attack. The Horned Frogs quietly have one of the best run defenses in the conference, allowing less than three yards per carry.
BYU’s ground game has been a machine. Martin is averaging over 100 yards per game, and the Cougars are averaging 6.7 yards per carry as a team. That’s with only limited use of QB Bear Bachmeier’s legs so far this season.
Anticipation is building for BYU-Notre Dame, now just two weeks from Saturday. But the Cougars have to take care of business first to set up a top-ten showdown.
Cincinnati Can Make Another Statement
Cincinnati (4-0, 1-0) at Arizona (3-1, 0-1) – 10:00 Fox
Line: Arizona -6.5
If you’re shocked by Cincinnati’s 4-0 start, you shouldn’t be.
September and October haven’t been the issue for the Bearcats during the Scott Satterfield era. They started 5-2 in 2024 and 7-1 last season, with College Gameday even covering their game at Utah.
Unfortunately for Cincy, it’s all come crashing down in November. But if you’re Arizona, this isn’t the time you want to see the Bearcats.
Nobody wants to see Bearcats RB Cole Tabb right now. He’s averaging a ridiculous 11.1 yards per carry, the best mark among FBS running backs with at least ten carries. He’s also scored six touchdowns in the last two weeks alone.
Only West Virginia is averaging more yardage on the ground than Cincy. QB JC French only had to throw 13 passes to put 31 points on K-State last week.
Arizona’s strategy is a little different.
QB Noah Fifita is working on another All-Big 12-caliber season, completing over 75% of his passes for 1,131 yards, 11 touchdowns, and only two interceptions. He has to be licking his chops at a Cincy defense that has already allowed 16 passes of 20 or more yards and ranks 117th nationally against the pass.
The Bearcats have to limit the damage from Fifita’s arm to come away with a win.
If either team wants to seriously chase a Big 12 title, this is a must-win game. Arizona entered the season believing it could contend, and it can’t afford a second conference loss with Texas Tech and Utah still on the schedule.
Rep your school without carrying a brick in your pocket! Thread has slim college wallets for nearly every Big 12 school, and after using one myself, I’ll never go back to a traditional bulky wallet.
Shop your team here and use code OFB15 for 15% off!
Is a Contender Hiding in Tempe?
Baylor (3-1, 1-0) at Arizona State (2-1, 1-0) – 9:30 ESPN
Line: ASU -3.5
The only blemish on either team’s résumé is a loss away from home to an SEC opponent, though neither defeat has aged well.
I’ve been bullish on Arizona State, but maybe I need to open my eyes to Baylor, too.
New defensive coordinator Joe Klanderman has done an outstanding job this season. The Bears are disruptive up front, tied for fourth in the country with 15 sacks.
ASU QB Cutter Boley melted down in the fourth quarter at Texas A&M when the Aggies’ front seven got home. Can the Bears generate that kind of pressure consistently?
Boley has generally been very good this season, though his last five quarters have brought him back down to earth.
Watch out for what Arizona State’s secondary could do to Baylor QB DJ Lagway. He has brilliant arm talent but is still raw and erratic. The Sun Devils have a top-20 pass defense and have been excellent at limiting big plays.
With Lagway, you’re guaranteed to get some big plays and some head-scratching plays.
Head coach Dave Aranda expects Lagway to be better now that he’s knocked off the rust after missing two games with an ankle injury. If he finds consistency, the Bears will be hard to stop.
I expect this to be a tight battle.
Who Can Bounce Back?
West Virginia (3-1, 0-1) at Iowa State (2-2, 0-1) – 11:00 TNT
Line: ISU -3
It’s fair to say West Virginia and Iowa State have both exceeded most people’s expectations so far this season. Each fought valiantly in a loss to a Big 12 contender last week.
Now one of them is going to get back on track.
The matchup to watch is easy to spot. It’s strength-on-strength when the Mountaineers try to run the ball.
WVU averages a league-best 295 rushing yards per game. Head coach Rich Rodriguez’s offense isn’t shy about its identity, either. The Mountaineers run the ball 57 times per game.
But that’s where Iowa State excels. The Cyclones held each of their first three opponents under 100 yards rushing, including #14 Iowa. Their defense controlled the game in Iowa City, only to be let down by a meager offensive performance.
Utah exposed some cracks, though. The Utes opened last week’s win in Ames with a 54-yard TD run from Wayshawn Parker, who finished with 174 rushing yards. Will the same opportunity be there for WVU’s dynamic duo of QB Michael Hawkins and RB Cam Cook?
We could be in for a real rock fight in this one.
Houston Has No Room for Error
UCF (3-1, 1-0) at #20 Houston (3-1, 0-1) – 11:00 ESPN2
Line: Houston -11.5
After a gut-wrenching two-point loss at Texas Tech, Houston doesn’t have much room for error in its quest to take the next step and make the Big 12 championship game.
The Cougars are keenly aware of their recent rise in stature. So much so that there’s plenty of frustration over this game landing in the 11 AM slot.
Houston AD Eddie Nuñez alerted the conference a year ago that the Cougars wanted anything but an 11 AM kickoff for this game because of their Hall of Honor gala on Friday night. Nuñez believes Houston has earned the right to night games after a 10-win season and a top-20 ranking.
Believe it or not, the Cougars have hosted only one conference night game since the start of the 2024 season.
On the field, UCF doesn’t seem equipped to exploit Houston’s biggest weakness, its pass defense. The Knights’ identity is built around a ground game that averages nearly six yards per carry. And they’re playing without starting QB Alonza Barnett III.
To his credit, backup QB Keyone Jenkins completed 19 of 20 passes for 160 yards in the Knights’ win over TCU last week. UCF probably needs more of that to spring the upset.
What You Need to Know
The Senate passed the Protect College Sports Act overwhelmingly, with 77 votes. It has a long road to make it through the House, though. I talked through the bill with AFCA Executive Director Craig Bohl last week.
BYU has a major injury issue on its offensive line. Are the Cougars as injured as they’ve ever been this early in a Big 12 season? Great discussion here.
One Big 12 team had a players-only meeting this week to try to turn its season around.
Reports indicate Colorado has a new starting quarterback.
Iowa State head coach Jimmy Rogers has quite a message for Cyclones fans.
Want your Big 12 news and analysis in podcast form? Listen to Open For Business at the gym, in your car, or first thing in the morning on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or YouTube.
Enjoying Open For Business? It would mean the world to me if you could share the newsletter with three of your friends who want Big 12 news without SEC or Big Ten bias. Tell them to sign up at OFBNews.com and get started today!
